Our Doctor Who expert, Tony Cross, is journeying through all of time and space to bring us his thoughts on every available Doctor story. Today is the Fifth Doctor adventure Earthshock...
I have said before in these articles that I have been interested to see which stories survive a repeated viewing unscathed. I found Tomb of the Cybermen a much less impressive story this time around for example so with Earthshock I wondered whether its status as something of a Classic would stand up.
After all this is a story I adored on its broadcast but as JNT infamously said: "The memory cheats".
But this is a delight. Sometimes despite itself. Let's take the often commented upon casting of Beryl Reid as the grumpy, no nonsense space freighter Captain Briggs. It shouldn't work. It's such an off beam casting choice but somehow it does & in doing so is one of the most adorable guest star performances in Doctor Who history. Interestingly Briggs's pilot-navigator-engineer is also a woman over the age of 30, Berger (June Bland). Both of them seem to take great delight in mocking the over-zealous jobsworth & Cyberspy Ringway (Alec Sabin) who is a bloke.
The sight of Beryl Reid firing a laser at advancing Cybermen makes me want to cheer.
This is the first appearance of the Cybermen in Doctor Who since Revenge of the Cybermen back in Tom Baker's first season & their sudden appearance Terry Nation stylee at the cliff-hanger to Episode One is brilliant. JNT turned down a Radio Times cover in order to keep that a surprise for which we should be grateful.
Being the Cybermen they've been redesigned for their reappearance & look pretty good except - alas - for the moonboots. You've heard me whinge on about the feet of Doctor Who monsters often enough but this one is a bit annoying, especially as we seen lots of moon booted Cybermen marching towards our screens at the end of Episode Three. However the seriousness applies to this story makes the Cybermen seem genuinely nasty in this story.
This is the first outing for David Banks as The Cyberleader. He would go on to play the Cyberleader - or his replacements - a number of times & took the role seriously enough to write a book about the Cybermen & to try and get their story to make some kind of sense. I used to love that commitment (and he was very nice when I queued up to get his autograph the *cough* four times I saw the Doctor Who Stage Play). However Banks's Cybermen do not have the sing-song electronic voices of old (or New Series) Cybermen & for a race that is supposed to have eliminated emotions they do a lot of emoting. Eventually some of Banks's Cyberleader would be the monster with catchphrases: most notably a triumphant 'Excellent!' often accompanied by the slamming of fist into hand. In this his first run out it doesn't matter too much & they make more interesting monsters when the Doctor can take them on in debate.
There's some nice support from James Warwick as Scott, the military officer (moustache a necessity) who gets to be suitably heroic. Clare Clifford as Kyle gets to run around a lot in an unfetching outfit before becoming one of the first of Eric Saward's 'nice person to kill off unnecessarily in the end for no particularly good reason'. I think Saward thinks this adds a touch of realistic cynicism to proceeding and it might be fine if this story wasn't going to end with a far more important death. So in the end Kyle's death is thrown away, drowned in the pathos of Adric's passing.
The moment has come. I come to bury Adric. I have been somewhat down on Matthew Waterhouse's acting skills since Peter Davison took over & even in this, his swansong, there are moments that lack conviction but I don't entirely think that's his fault. Waterhouse was going from child actor to grown up & that's a tough journey for anyone & asking him to play a major part in a popular BBC programme might have been too much to ask.
However we can't complain too much as he gets one of the best departures - if that's the right word for what happens to poor old Adric - of any companion. Doctor Who companions don't die. The Doctor always pulls something out of the hat to save them. This time he doesn't & Adric dies. He dies alone - the boy standing on the burning deck - on the bridge proving that when he said he was tired of being an outsider it wasn't hyperbole, he was an outsider.
The Doctor's desperate attempts to save him & horrified reaction when he realises that he can't is well-played by Peter Davison. In fact Davison is excellent throughout this story & his Doctor has grown on me a lot since Castrovalva. He's so understated.
So perhaps the memory doesn't always cheat after all.
Tony Cross is the creator of the wonderful Centurion Blog's found HERE and HERE.
Image – BBC.